Our Etsy Reviews

▸ These reviews were published on June 18, 2026 when we left Etsy.

Showing 24 of 370 reviews
★★★★★

“Such great quality work on this proxy!! I haven’t see the real one, but there is so much attention to detail. Package also arrived very quickly! Would highly recommend!”

★★★★★

“Great quality print and foil! There is a lot of attention to detail. Not to mention that shipping was super fast! Would highly recommend”

★★★★★

“Absolutely perfect! Exactly as pictured. I will definitely be buying from them again. Their customer service and response time is top tier!”

★★★★★

“Great quality and quick shipping!”

★★★★★

“Looks and feels very high quality.”

★★★★★

“the product arrived as expected in excellent condition and pretty quickly”

★★★★★

“the card is great quality, arrived fast and it beyond what is normal”

★★★★★

“Here are some words ok”

★★★★★

“Card was shipped out fast and looks practically indistinguishable from real MTG cards from the art quality to the card stock.”

★★★★★

“The card was shipped out faster than expected and arrived in solid packaging. The foil effect and card art quality is absolutely phenomenal and goes above and beyond what I expected. Excited to run this for my MTG nights.”

★★★★★

“ProxyUSA U are the best my guy. Keep doing u. I’ll be buying all of my proxies from u from now on. I’ve bought from other Sellers before and . no one has come as close to your level of quality. Literally almost identical to the real WOTC cards. 👌🏼👌🏼👌🏼”

★★★★★

“Great proxy for an impossible to get card.”

★★★★★

“Card quality and printing is very nice”

★★★★★

“Fantastic Proxy. Card quality and printing is really nice.”

★★★★★

“Item as described, nice quality, well packaged, quick shipping. Thanks.”

★★★★★

“Fast shipping, exactly as described. Great graphics.”

★★★★★

“Amazing quality appreciate the level of craftsmanship”

★★★★★

“As described in quality condition”

★★★★★

“Amazing product got for a gift and he loved it!!!”

★★★★★

“Awesome quality, arrived quickly, looks amazing”

★★★★★

“seller was very helpful and responded quickly! will purchase from them again!”

★★★★★

“Really good quality proxies. Will definatily buy again!”

★★★★★

“Looks great, feels just like a magic card”

★★★★★

“Highly recommended excellent work thank you fast delivery”