▸ These reviews were published on June 18, 2026 when we left Etsy.
“Feels like a commander deck. Missing the red mana card, but otherwise great.”
“Really good quality and the foiling is very well done”
“Feels great and quick response time”
“Actually looks real. You can tell it's layered on a legit mtg card if you look hard enough. Good foil quality and the border looks phenomenal.”
“Great product and fast delivery.”
“Item arrived in a timely manner. Quality is fantastic - as near to standard MTG cards as you could be. Foil looks great. Would certainly buy from this seller again”
“Great quality and easy transaction. Would do business with again.”
“fantastic quality and customer service!!”
“Great cards! Just as described and fits in sleeves just like my normal cards”
“exactly as described. perfect for my deck.”
“I picked this up after the whole stupid secret layer ordering fiasco but I was honestly pretty impressed with the quality. The cards feel really close to regular Magic cards in terms of thickness and how they handle, and the print quality looks great overall. The deck was put together well, and everything arrived clean and organized. The only small thing I notified on the printing of some of the older cards and a few of the card set icons does look a little off but that being said it was a very minor issue and all these cards still feel freaking fantastic. Overall, this is an awesome proxy set, especially for the price. The quality was better than I expected, and I'd definitely buy from this seller again. I'd happily recommend it to anyone looking for a solid proxy deck.”
“Great product. Would buy again!”
“Great proxy for anyone who wants to play with old school Magic the gathering cards! Quick Shipping!”
“I have been wanting this card for a while, but the prices. Thanks”
“Pretty amazing work and right on time!”
“Saved me a lot while getting a fantastic card - win”
“Very nice! Keep up the good work!”
“Really good quality and right on time.”
“This proxied goblin storm commander deck is phenomenal. If this seller did at request custom commander decks I would rate 100/10, take my money, 🤣.”
“I love it thank you!”
“One of the best I’ve seen. Looks amazing!”
“Thank you. Everthing was ok. :)”
“Thank you. Everthing was ok. :)”
“Thank you very much. The Cards have high Qualität: )”