Our Etsy Reviews

▸ These reviews were published on June 18, 2026 when we left Etsy.

Showing 24 of 370 reviews
★★★★★

“As described and great quality”

★★★★★

“came with a deck box with all 100 cards in it and seller threw in a extra goodie 😉 definitely recommend if you wanna pick up the goblin storm secret lair but not for crazy scalper prices or if you just want proxies in general this seller kills it”

★★★★★

“Great quality card, love it!”

★★★★★

“again great proxies, will be ordering from again :)”

★★★★★

“great proxies, fast shipping and overall really happy with the service, would happily buy from again :)”

★★★★★

“Excellent proxy! High quality and looks great for displaying my commander. This is the 2nd card I ordered from this shop and I'm very pleased.”

★★★★★

“Excellent proxy! High quality and looks great for displaying my commander”

★★★★★

“the quality is exactly what I was hoping for!”

★★★★★

“card came in great condition and is easily identifiable as a proxy thanks to the back. very satisfied with my purchase!”

★★★★★

“Great quality on cards specially on the raised foil ones! shipping was quick and all questions were answered and resolved quick!”

★★★★★

“Top border is slightly large, and card thickness is slightly thin, but it’s amazing quality. I highly recommend this seller”

★★★★★

“Great looking card and just as described.”

★★★★★

“Item shipped quickly and arrived in great condition. Easy transaction and would do business with again. Thank you!”

★★★★★

“Super high quality proxies, maybe even better quality than the genuine article. Amazing customer service/communication as well, will definitely be ordering again in the future!”

★★★★★

“Exactly what I was wanting and it got here fast! Can't wait to play with this deck!”

★★★★★

“Now I can pretend to have an insanely expensive card. Sits happily in my artifacts deck. Will buy from again.”

★★★★★

“I have no complaints. Will buy from again”

★★★★★

“Looks like the real thing!”

★★★★★

“foils look amazing and quality is just a good as real magic stock. definitely worth the purchase imo”

★★★★★

“Could hardly tell it was a proxy sometimes”

★★★★★

“Great card to play test with .”

★★★★★

“Great quality, very satisfied with the proxy I received.”

★★★★★

“Great quality card, love the design.”

★★★★★

“Fast, high quality print”